Too Many Wise Men?

How many men does it take to run the economy? Numerous, going by the number of experts voicing their opinion in Delhi.

The multiple lines of economic command have been visible for some time now. If there were ever any doubts, one had to only tune into the babble of eco-speak emanating from Delhi soon after the wholesale price index numbers for February were announced. There was understandable panic because the inflation rate was nudging the treacherous double-digit mark. But, going by the comments made, it would seem that there were many more people out there in Delhi who knew what the Reserve Bank should be doing and when it should be timing its next action. And, then came the unexpected RBI rate hike to quell some of the inflationary flames. But, instead of diminishing, the decibel level actually went up by a few notches with the experts now holding forth that RBI needed to implement another rate hike.

But, what has been described above is only a symptom of a larger trend in economic policy management. Over the past few years, the number of ecocrats has multiplied and with it have the number the divergent views and conflicting opinions. All this is, of course, great grist for the electronic media.

Here’s a look at the chief policy manager and the various people in the economic management team.

· Prime minister Manmohan Singh: An established economist with pucca Oxbridge cred. Gained respect worldwide for having pulled the Indian economy back from the brink of bankruptcy and then steering it out of the stifling, controlled regime to a new liberal and competitive framework.
· C Rangarajan: Another well regarded economist. The former RBI governor is currently the Chairman of the Prime Minister’s Economic Advisory Committee. Obviously, knows his monetary onions well and makes them public as well.
· Montek Singh Ahluwalia: Another Oxbridge-World Bank alum who gained fame as an economic advisor during Rajiv Gandhi’s time. Was Chief Economic Advisor in finance ministry when Manmohan Singh was finance minister. Is currently Deputy Chairman of the Planning Commission. A favourite with the sound-bite hunters on all topics – from the state of the monsoons to the interest rate structure.
· Kaushik Basu: A vociferous champion of free economy, this former don – he taught at Delhi School of Economics and Cornell University – has been recently appointed as Chief Economic Advisor to the finance minister. He is the hunting pack’s new quarry.
· Pronab Sen: Chief Statistician, Sen is currently trying to overhaul the way data is collected, tossed and diced, and then the manner in which the decision-making apparatus interprets it. He has also been vocal with his views on inflation and interest rates.
· Raghuram Rajan: Occupant of tenured chair at University of Chicago and a former Chief Economist at IMF, this man has been quietly advising the PM on a number of issues, including financial sector reforms. The super regulator proposed in Budget 2010 – which is expected to supercede all the other financial sector regulators in the country, such as RBI, SEBI, IRDA — was suggested by the panel headed by him.
· Pranab Mukherjee: The man who, as finance minister, is in the thick of it but does not speak much at all, except to voice the government’s overall concern from time to time over inflation, interest rates and their impact on credit growth and the general well-being in the economy.
· D Subbarao: Governor at RBI, who played an impressive role in launching the fire-fighting operations in close coordination with the fiscal authorities soon after Lehman Brothers went belly up. He is also trying to improve some of RBI’s traditional ways (such as, communication), but unfortunately that is seen as a weakness and he is considered fair game by everyone in Delhi. So, almost every ecocrat has a word of advice for him.

There is nothing wrong in having such a large and high-calibre team of economists in charge of policy management. But, policy direction starts sounding out of whack when all of them speak in different and contradictory tongues.

Advertisements

One thought on “Too Many Wise Men?

  1. Each of the names above, has had zero practical life experience in spending. Thru their lives, they have lived off the fat of the land. Perks, tax free world bank pensions, consultancy income to spouse etc etc., it is but natural, that the statements are tempered by politics. When your brain is stifled by a bandage, thoughts do not flow.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s